Skip to text

Chapter 33 of 33 · Part 2 of 3 · approx. 14 min

Chapter XXXIII: The Empire

He looked on the world as so sunk in corruption that it was impossible to speak gravely. Therefore he employed “goblet words” which apply in various directions; he based his statements upon weighty authority in order to inspire confidence; and he put words in other people’s mouths in order to secure breadth.

See ch. xxvii ad init.

In accord with the spirit of the universe, he was at peace with all creation. He judged not the rights and wrongs of mankind, and thus lived quietly in his generation. Although his book is an extraordinary production, it is plausible and harmless enough. Although the style is most irregular, it is at the same time ingenious and attractive.

As a thinker, he is endlessly suggestive. Above, he roams with God. Below, he consorts with those who are beyond the pale of life and death, who deny a beginning and an end. In relation to the root,

The origin of all things.

he speaks on a grand and extensive scale. In relation to TAO, he establishes a harmony between man and the higher powers. Nevertheless, he yields to the modifications of existence and responds to the exigencies of environment. His arguments are inexhaustible, and never illogical. He is far-reaching, mysterious, and not to be fully explored.

It is impossible for a European critic to believe that Chuang Tzŭ penned the above paragraphs. See post, p. 454.

Hui Tzŭ was a man of many ideas. His works would fill five carts. But his doctrines are paradoxical, and his terms are used ambiguously.

He calls infinite greatness, beyond which there is nothing, the Greater One. He calls infinite smallness, within which there is nothing, the Lesser One.

Recognising two absolute extremes.

He says that that which is without dimensions measures a thousand li.

On the principle that mathematical points, though themselves without dimensions, collectively fill up space.

That heaven and earth are equally low. That mountain and marsh are equally level.

It depends upon the point of view.

That the sun at noon is the sun setting.

To people living farther east.

That when an animal is born, it dies.

As regards its previous state it dies when leaving it for a new state.

That the likeness of things partly unlike is called the lesser likeness of unlikes. That the likeness of things altogether unlike is called the greater likeness of unlikes. That southwards there is no limit, and yet there is a limit. That one can reach Yüeh to-day and yet be there before. That joined rings can be separated. That the middle of the world is north of Yen and south of Yüeh.

It is wherever the speaker is. The space between Yen and Yüeh is as zero compared with the infinite.

That he loves all creation equally, just as heaven and earth are impartial to all.

In covering and supporting all.

Accordingly, Hui Tzŭ was regarded as a great philosopher and a very subtle dialectician; and became a favourite with the other dialecticians of the day.

He said that there were feathers in an egg.

Because on a chicken.

That a fowl had three feet.

The third being volition.

That Ying was the world.

As you cannot say it is not the world.

That a dog could be a sheep. That a mare could lay eggs. That a nail has a tail.

Names being arbitrary in all cases.

That fire is not hot.

It is the man who feels it hot.

That mountains have mouths.

As evidenced by echoes.

That wheels do not press down the ground.

Touching only at a point.

That the eye does not see.

It is the man.

That the finger does not touch. That the uttermost extreme is not the end. That a tortoise is longer than a snake.

Because longer lived!

That a carpenter’s square is not square.

Like Horace’s Whetstone which makes other things sharp, “exsors ipsa secandi.”

That compasses will not make a circle.

It is the draughtsman.

That a round hole will not surround a square handle. That the shadow of a flying bird does not move. That there is a moment when a swiftly-flying arrow is neither moving nor at rest. That a dog is not a hound.

Two things cannot be identical unless even their names are the same.

That a bay horse and a dun cow are three.

Taken separately they are two. Taken together they are one. One and two make three.

That a white dog is black.

If his eyes are black. Part standing for the whole.

That a motherless colt never had a mother.

When it had a mother, it was not an orphan.

That if you take a stick a foot long and every day cut it in half, you will never come to the end of it.

Compare “Achilles and the Tortoise,” and the sophisms of the Greek philosophers.

And such was the stuff which dialecticians used to argue about with Hui Tzŭ, also without ever getting to the end of it.

Huan T’uan and Kung Sun Lung were of this class. By specious premisses they imposed on people’s minds and drove them into false conclusions. But though they won the battle in words, they did not carry conviction into their adversaries’ hearts. Theirs were but the snares of the sophist.

Hui Tzŭ daily devoted his intelligence to such pursuits, purposely advancing some preposterous thesis upon which to dispute. That was his characteristic. He had besides a great opinion of his own wisdom, and used to say, “The universe does not hold my peer.”

Hui Tzŭ makes a parade of his strength, but is devoid of any sound system. An eccentric fellow in the south, named Huang Liao, asked why the sky did not fall and the earth sink; also, whence came wind, rain, and thunder.

Hui Tzŭ was not backward in replying to these questions, which he answered unhesitatingly. He went into a long discussion on all creation, and talked away without end, though to himself he seemed to be saying very little. He supplemented this with most extraordinary statements, making it his chief object to contradict others, and being desirous of gaining fame by defeating all comers. Thus, he was never popular. Morally, he was weak; physically, he was violent. His was a dark and narrow way.

Looked at from the point of view of the TAO of the universe, the value of Hui Tzŭ may be compared with the efforts of a mosquito or a gadfly. Of what use was he to the world? As a specialist, he might have succeeded. But to let him put himself forward as an exponent of TAO, would have been dangerous indeed.

He would not however be content to be a specialist. He must needs roam insatiably over all creation, though he only succeeded in securing the reputation of a sophist.

Alas for the talents of Hui Tzŭ! He is extravagantly energetic, and yet has no success. He investigates all creation, but does not conclude in TAO. He makes a noise to drown an echo. He is like a man running a race with his own shadow. Alas!

As to the genuineness of this concluding chapter, every one may form his own opinion. The question has been hotly fought, and great names could be mentioned on each side. Wang An Shih and Su Tung P’o both thought that it might well have come from the hand of Chuang Tzŭ. Lin Hsi Chung thought not, and on his side the majority of Western students will in all probability be ranged.

INDEX

Accidentals, 162

Achilles and the Tortoise, 453

Action, 5, 266, 293

Affirmative and Negative, 17

Aggression, 340

Ai, Duke, 62, 268, 429

Ai Fêng, 29

Ai T’ai T’o, 62

All-in-extremes, 276

Alternation theory, 18

Anger, 310

Ants and Mutton, 330

Apricot Altar, 413

Archery, 60, 255, 272, 308, 309, 318

Argument, Futility of, 30

Arms, Appeal to, 162

Arms, Men of, 318

Artificial, The, 147, 175, 210, 232, 309

Augur and the pigs, The Grand, 236

Balancing balls, 233

Bantams, 297

Battered but not Bruised, 80

Battering-ram, 207

Battle, The Six Plans of, 313

Beauty, 182, 260, 337

Bells, Chime of, 250

Bird, The strange, 258

Bishop-wort, 313

Black Forest, The, 413

Black Water, The, 276

Blades from Kan, 193

Boats, 75, 249, 295

Body, The human, 15; (without body) 145

Body and soul parted, 12, 324

Bogy, A, 236

Books, 170

Boots, (for the toeless) 63; (outside door) 368, 424

Border-warden, The, 141

Breathing from the heels, 69

Business, 133

Butcher, The faithful, 376

Butterfly, Chuang Tzŭ a, 32

Canon of Confucianism, 166, 188, 312, 438, 439

Cataract, A, 238

Caterpillars, 297

Cats, 312; (wild) 10

Centipede, The, 211

Ceremonial, 89, 108, 121, 133, 162, 195, 277, 318, 440

Chance, 350

Chan Tzŭ, 380

Ch’ang Chi, 56

Chang Hung, 112

Ch’ang Hung, 352

Chang I, 235

Chang Jo, 316

Chang Wu Tzŭ, 28

Ch’ang Yü, 316

Chao Hsi, 373

Chao Wên, 22

Chapped hands, Salve for, 9

Charioteering, 241

Charity, 88, 100, 101, 108, 114, 122, 133, 277, 307

Chê, Robber, 103, 112, 120, 155, 387

Ch’êns and Ts’ais, 180, 251, 253, 255, 380

Chê-yang, The, 154

Ch’êng, 281

Chêng K’ao Fu, 431

Chêng State, The, 59, 94

Ch’i, Mt., 372

Ch’i Kung, 261

Ch’i State, The, 50, 65, 110

Ch’i-yang, 384

Chi Ch’ê, 145, 146

Chi-yung, 331

Chi T’o, 72, 361

Chi Tzŭ (1) 72, 352; (2) 339

Chi Chên, 350

Chi Ch’ih, 442

Chi Chü, 45

Chi Hsing Tzŭ, 238

Chi Han, Magician, 94

Chiang Lü Mien, 145, 146

Chieh, 40, 119, 383

Chieh-kêng, 331

Chieh Tzŭ, 350

Chieh Yü, 7, 55, 92

Chien Ho, 353

Chien Wu, 6, 77, 92, 273

Chih, 206

Ch’ih Chang Man Chi, 152

Ch’ih Chi, 207

Chih-ho, 354

Chih Kung, 401

Ch’ih Yu, 392

Children, 299, 300, 301, 358

Chin, Duke of, 29

Chin State, The, 147

Ch’in Hua Li, 440

Ch’in Lao, 342

Chin-shao, The, 226, 244

Ch’in Shih, 36

Ch’in State, The, 368

Ch’ing, Carpenter, 240

Ch’ing-ning, The, 228

Ching-shih, 53

Ching Shou, The, 33

Ch’iu (Confucius), 145, 189

Chiu Fang Yin, 327

Ch’iu-shih, 426

Chiu-yu, The, 228

Chŏ-lu, 392

Chou, 40

Chou, River, 383

Chou Kung, 181, 384

Chrysalis, 3

Chu Hsien, 234

Chu Yung, 116

Ch’u State, The, 3 et alt. pass.

Chuan Hsü, 77

Chuang, Duke, 241

Chuang Tzŭ, 9, (and the butterfly) 32; 66, 137, 159, 215, 216, (asked to take office) 217, 434, (and the fishes) 218, (death of wife) 223, (and the skull) 224, (and the geese) 245; 254, 258, 268, (and TAO) 285, 318, (at Hui Tzŭ’s grave) 321, (and the stickleback) 353, (and the useless) 358, (on Confucius) 365; 407, 427, (death of) 434, (his genius) 449

Chui, 115, 242

Chun Mang, 150

Chung, 332

Chung Yang, 116

Chü Ch’iao, 28

Chü Liang, 88

Chü Poh Yü, 49, 345

Ch’ü-to, 228

Chü Tzŭ, 442

Chü Tzŭ, Mt., 316

Chü Yüan, 50

Cicadas, 2, 258, 306, (catching) 232

Class distinctions, 187

Classification, 168

Clouds and rain, 165, 173

Cocks and dogs, 117, 350

Cock-fighting, 238

Coffins, 53, 441

Cold, Latent, 319

Colossal, The, 204

Colour Sense, The, 99, 108, 115, 121, 155

Common-places, 154

Complacency, 402

Concentration, 34, 240, 300

Conditioned, The, 158

Confucius, 28, 38, 45, 55, 56, (and the leper) 62, 83, (and Lao Tzŭ) 144, 166, 182, 184, 188, 266, 282; 149, 179, 182, 201, (in danger) 213, 251; 225, (on concentration) 232, 235, (at the cataract)

238; 253, 255, 263, 272, 274, 282, 290, 291, 325, 338, 341, 346, (and Lao Lai Tzŭ) 356; (changed his opinions) 365; 366, (and Robber Chê) 387; 429

Conscription, 54

Cooks, 6, 33, 104

Correlatives, 207, 208

Corpse, (boy who impersonates) 6, 97; (singing near a) 83

Cunning, 315

Crane’s legs, A, 101, 332

Criteria (of our minds), 16, (of Confucius), 166

Dark, Seeing in the, 139

Dark Palace, The, 77

Dark-Steep Mt., The, 276

Death. See Life and Death.

Death of Chuang Tzŭ’s wife, 223

Destiny, 46, 64, 74, 90, 143, 189, 258

Determinate relations, 332

Dialecticians, 318

Dimensions, 202

Discontent, 402

Discord and accord, 320

Distance relative, 2

Diversity, 331

Divination, 357

Divine Man, 7, 85, 151, 193, 331, 361

Divine Teacher, The, 317

Do-nothing Say-nothing, 276

Doctrine of Silence, 56

Dogs, (straw) 180, (how to judge of) 312, 327, (why they bark) 350

Dog-tooth violet, 228

Doorkeepers, 320, 329

Doubts, 102, 117, 244, 334

Dove, young, 2, 306

Dragon, Lao Tzŭ a, 185

Dragons, 214, 263

Dragon-power, 122, 185

Dream, Life a, 30, 86

Dreamless sleep, 82, 192

Dregs of knowledge, 172

Drugs, 299, 331

Drunken man, A, 232

Duck’s legs, A, 101

Duckweed, 228

Dust-bin, Spirit of the, 237

Duty, 46, 88, 101, 108, 114, 121, 122, 133, 166, 277, 298, 307, 367, 433

Dying, No advantage in not, 15

Ear, The, 333

Earth, 161, 173, 223; (music of) 12

Eel’s habitat, The, 27, 295

Ego, Whence the, 14

Emotions, 308

Empyrean, The, 288

Energy, Hu Tzŭ shows his internal, 96

Enthusiasts, 330

Essentials, 162

Evil speakers, 39

Excalibur, 82, 303

Exhaling and inhaling, 191

Existence and non-existence, 206, 304

External, The, 49, 82, 103, 156, 235, 299, 302, 310, 315

Extremes meet, 115

Eye, The, 211, 333

Fa Yen, The, 47

Failure, Causes of, 432

Fallacia amphiboliæ, 275

Fame or Reputation, 5, 103

Fan, Prince of, 275

Fang Ming, 316

Fasting, 42, 43, 282

Father praising son, 363

Fên-yang, 8

Fêng Mêng, 255

Fighting, 207, 315

Fighting-cocks, 238

Filial piety, 153, 175, 186, 361

Finger, 19

Fire eternal, 37

Fire Spirit, The, 237

Fire, Production of, 353

First Cause, 246, 267

Fisherman, 357

Fishes, 114, 174, 185, 295, 296, 331, 354; happiness of, 218

Fish-hawks, 189

Five Bonds, The, 399

Five Princes, 78

Five Rulers, The, 186, 202

Flattery, 153

Fools, 154

Foot, The, 333

Foot-prints, 188

Footsteps, Afraid of his, 418

Forgetfulness, 65

Form, 144, 297

Forms and Name, 163

Four Seas, The, 123, 151, 202

Foxes, 247, 295

Friendship, 253

Frog of the Well, 201, 215

Fu Hsi, 45, 77, 116, 196, 274

Fu Yüeh, 78

Fulness and decay, 203, 287

Gain, 103

Gambling, 234

Geese, 297

Gentleness, 123

Glow-worm, 228

Glue, Sticking without, 102

God, 1, 15, 31, 68, 82, 163, 257, 282, 301, 333

Goitre, A large, 65

Golden Age, 116, 152

Golden Roster, 313

Goose, The cackling, 245

Gourd, Five-bushel, 9

Government, (a curse) 92; 107, 114, 119, 123, 130, 132, 146; (by the true Sage) 151; 163, 164, 186, 187, 317

Grand Augur, The, 236

Grand Tutor, 272

Grave, Opening a, 355

Great Bear, The, 77

Great truths, 154

Great Yü, The, 16, 142, 152, 215, 254

Grief, Real, 85

Han-ch’ih, The, 176

Han-tan, 216, 217; (siege of) 113

Han-yin, 147

Happiness, (in inaction) 158, 159, (elements of) 220, 405, (of fishes) 218, (and sorrow) 199, 221

Hard and White, The, 22, 67, 100, 117

Hê Hsü, 116

Hearing, Sense of, 99, 104, 115, 121, 311, 333, 359

Heart, Natural goodness of, 123, (the seat of intellect) 297

Heat, Latent, 319

Heaven, 161, 173, 223

Hermaphrodites, 189

Heron, 366

Ho Hsü, 109

Ho-shang, 434

Horses, 19, 106, 209, 228, 285, 312, 316, 347

Hou I or Yi, 60, 255, 308, 309, 319

House, A, 306

Hsi P’êng, 316, 322

Hsi Shih knits her brows, 182

Hsi Wang Mu, 78

Hsi Wei, 76, 292, 346

Hsi Wei Shih, 359

Hsiang-ch’êng, 316

Hsiang Li Ch’in, 442

Hsiao Chi, 352

Hsiao Poh (Duke Huan), 399

Hsien of the Kung-wêns, 35

Hsien-ch’ih, The, 227

Hsien Yüan, 116

Hsin, The, 237

Hsü (butterflies), 228

Hsü-aos, The, 26, 40

Hsü Wu Kuei, 311

Hsü Yu, 6, 87, 140, 329, 361, 382, 404, 432

Hsü Yü Chi T’o, 73, 361

Hu, 98

Hu Pu Hsieh, 72

Hu Tzŭ, 94

Hua, 141; (Mt.) 443

Hua Chi, 316

Hua Lin, 207

Hua Tzŭ, 339

Huan (Confucianist), 426

Huan of Ch’i, Duke, 65, 170, 236, 322, 399

Huan Tou, 124

Huan T’uan, 453

Huang-chung, 100

Huang-hua, The, 154

Huang-k’uang, The, 228

Huang Liao, 453

Huang Ti. See Yellow Emperor

Huang Tzŭ Kao Ngao, 236

Hui, Prince, 33, (of Wei) 338

Hui Tzŭ, 8, 66, 217, 218, 223, 318, 321, 341, 358, 361, 365, 450

Hunchbacks, 55, 65, 224, 232

Hun Tun, 98

I, Mt., 341

I Chieh, 335

I-êrh, The, 251

I Êrh Tzŭ, 87

I Liao, 247, 325, 342

I-lu, 228

I Yin, 309, 383

Immunity of Drunkards, 232

Inaction, 80, 97, 122, 131, 134, 136, 137, 158, 159, 160, 165, 222, 288, 308, 318

Infinite, One with the, 89

Infinitesimal, The, 204

Influences, The Six, 129, 174

Instincts, 107

Intelligence, 139

Internal, The, 49, 122, 156, 235, 299, 302, 310, 315