Chapter 11 of 33 · Part 1 of 2 · approx. 10 min
Chapter XI: On Letting Alone
Argument:—The natural conditions of our existence require no artificial aids—The evils of government—Failure of coercion—TAO the refuge—Inaction the secret—The action of Inaction—Illustrations.
There has been such a thing as letting mankind alone; there has never been such a thing as governing mankind.
With success.
Letting alone springs from fear lest men’s natural dispositions be perverted and their virtue laid aside. But if their natural dispositions be not perverted nor their virtue laid aside, what room is there left for government?
Of old, when Yao governed the empire, he caused happiness to prevail to excess in man’s nature; and consequently the people were not satisfied. When Chieh
See p. 40.
governed the empire he caused sorrow to prevail to excess in man’s nature; and consequently the people were not contented. Dissatisfaction and discontent are subversive of virtue; and without virtue there is no such thing for an empire as stability.
Virtue, here in its ordinary sense.
When man rejoices greatly he gravitates towards the positive pole. When he sorrows deeply he gravitates towards the negative pole.
These “poles” are the male and female principles already alluded to on p. 82. Originally developed from the Great Monad, they became the progenitors of all creation.
If the equilibrium of positive and negative
In nature.
is disturbed, the four seasons are interrupted, the balance of heat and cold is destroyed, and man himself suffers physically thereby.
Because men are made to rejoice and to sorrow and to displace their centre of gravity, they lose their steadiness, and are unsuccessful in thought and action. And thus it is that the idea of surpassing others first came into the world, followed by the appearance of such men as Robber Chê, Tsêng, and Shih, the result being that the whole world could not furnish enough rewards for the good nor distribute punishments enough for the evil among mankind. And as this great world is not equal to the demand for rewards and punishments; and as, ever since the time of the Three Dynasties
The legendary emperors Fu Hsi, Shên Nung, and Huang Ti, or the Yellow Emperor, already mentioned.
downwards, men have done nothing but struggle over rewards and punishments,—what possible leisure can they have had for adapting themselves to the natural conditions of their existence?
Besides, over-refinement of vision leads to debauchery in colour; over-refinement of hearing leads to debauchery in sound; over-refinement of charity leads to confusion in virtue;
Here again the manifestation of TAO. See p. 45.
over-refinement of duty towards one’s neighbour leads to perversion of principle;
The eternal principles which are of TAO and not of man.
over-refinement of ceremonial leads to divergence from the true object; over-refinement of music leads to lewdness of thought; over-refinement of wisdom leads to an extension of mechanical art; and over-refinement of shrewdness leads to an extension of vice.
As shown in the preceding chapter.
If people adapt themselves to the natural conditions of existence, the above eight
Vision, hearing, charity, duty to one’s neighbour, ceremonial, music, wisdom, and shrewdness.
may be or may not be; it matters not. But if people do not adapt themselves to the natural conditions of existence, then these eight become hindrances and spoilers, and throw the world into confusion.
In spite of this, the world reverences and cherishes them, thereby greatly increasing the sum of human error. And not as a passing fashion, but with admonitions in words, with humility in prostrations, and with the stimulus of music and song. What then is left for me?
Therefore, for the perfect man who is unavoidably summoned to power over his fellows, there is naught like Inaction.
It is not according to the spirit of TAO that a man should shirk his mortal responsibilities. On the contrary, TAO teaches him how to meet them.
By means of inaction he will be able to adapt himself to the natural conditions of existence. And so it is that he who respects the State as his own body is fit to support it, and he who loves the State as his own body, is fit to govern it.
This last sentence is attributed by Huai Nan Tzŭ to Lao Tzŭ, and has been incorporated in the Tao-Tê-Ching, ch. xiii. It is curious that Chuang Tzŭ should say nothing about its authorship, and perhaps even more curious that Kuo Hsiang, his editor and commentator of the fourth century A.D., should say nothing either about the claims of Lao Tzŭ or the Tao-Tê-Ching.
And if I can refrain from injuring my internal economy, and from taxing my powers of sight and hearing, sitting like a corpse while my dragon-power is manifested around, in profound silence while my thunder-voice resounds, the powers of heaven responding to every phase of my will, as under the yielding influence of inaction all things are brought to maturity and thrive,—what leisure then have I to set about governing the world?
Some of this passage is repeated in ch. xiv.
Ts’ui Chü
A casual personage.
asked Lao Tzŭ, saying, “If the empire is not to be governed, how are men’s hearts to be kept in order?”
“Be careful,” replied Lao Tzŭ, “not to interfere with the natural goodness of the heart of man. Man’s heart may be forced down or stirred up. In each case the issue is fatal.
“By gentleness, the hardest heart may be softened. But try to cut and polish it,—’twill glow like fire or freeze like ice. In the twinkling of an eye it will pass beyond the limits of the Four Seas. In repose, profoundly still; in motion, far away in the sky. No bolt can bar, no bond can bind,—such is the human heart.”
“Of old, the Yellow Emperor first caused charity and duty to one’s neighbour to interfere with the natural goodness of the heart of man. In consequence of which, Yao and Shun wore the hair off their legs in endeavouring to feed their people. They disturbed their internal economy in order to find room for charity and duty to one’s neighbour. They exhausted their energies in framing laws and statutes. Still they did not succeed.
“Thereupon, Yao confined Huan Tou on Mount Tsung; drove the chief of San-miao and his people into San-wei, and kept them there; and banished the Minister of Works to Yu Island.
These words are quoted (with variants) from the Shu Ching or Canon of History. They refer to individuals who had misconducted themselves in carrying out the new régime.
But they were not equal to their task, and through the times of the Three Princes
The Great Yü, T’ang, and Wên Wang, founder of the Chou dynasty.
the empire was in a state of great unrest. Among the bad men were Chieh and Chê; among the good were Tsêng and Shih. By and by, the Confucianists and the Mihists arose; and then came exultation and anger of rivals, fraud between the simple and the cunning, recrimination between the virtuous and the evil, slander between the honest and the dishonest,—until decadence set in, men fell away from their original virtue, their natures became corrupt, and there was a general rush for knowledge.
“The next thing was to coerce by all kinds of physical torture, thus bringing utter confusion into the empire, the blame for which rests upon those who would interfere with the natural goodness of the heart of man.
“In consequence, virtuous men sought refuge in mountain caves, while rulers of States sat trembling in their ancestral halls. Then, when dead men lay about pillowed on each others’ corpses, when cangued prisoners and condemned criminals jostled each other in crowds,—then the Confucianists and the Mihists, in the midst of gyves and fetters, stood forth to preach!
Salvation from the ills of which they and their systems had been the cause.
Alas, they know not shame, nor what it is to blush!
“Until I can say that the wisdom of Sages is not a fastener of cangues, and that charity and duty to one’s neighbour are not bolts for gyves, how should I know that Tsêng and Shih are not the forerunners
Lit. “sounding arrows,” used by bandits as a signal for beginning the attack.
of Chieh and Chê?
The meaning intended is that good cannot exist without its correlative evil.
“Therefore I said, ‘Abandon wisdom and discard knowledge, and the empire will be at peace.’“
These words have been incorporated in ch. xix of the Tao-Tê-Ching. The present rendering somewhat modifies the view I expressed on p. 16 of The Remains of Lao Tzŭ.
The Yellow Emperor sat on the throne for nineteen years, and his laws obtained all over the empire.
Hearing that Kuang Ch’êng Tzŭ
Said by some commentators to be another name for Lao Tzŭ, but if so, then it must have been Lao Tzŭ as he existed, an incarnation of TAO, before his appearance in the Confucian age.
was living on Mount K’ung-t’ung, he went thither to see him, and said, “I am told, Sir, that you are in possession of perfect TAO. May I ask in what perfect TAO consists? I desire to avail myself of the good influence of heaven and earth in order to secure harvests and feed my people. I should also like to control the Two Powers of nature
The Yin and the Yang. See pp. 82, 120.
in order to the protection of all living things. How can I accomplish this?”
“What you desire to avail yourself of,” replied Kuang Ch’êng Tzŭ, “is the primordial integrity of matter. What you wish to control are the disintegrators thereof. Ever since the empire has been governed by you, the clouds have rained without waiting to thicken, the foliage of trees has fallen without waiting to grow yellow, the brightness of the sun and moon has paled, and the voice of the flatterer is heard on every side. How then speak of perfect TAO?”
The Yellow Emperor withdrew. He resigned the Throne. He built himself a solitary hut. He lay upon straw. For three months he remained in seclusion, and then went again to see Kuang Ch’êng Tzŭ.
The latter was lying down with his face to the south. The Yellow Emperor approached after the manner of an inferior, upon his knees. Prostrating himself upon the ground he said, “I am told, Sir, that you are in possession of perfect TAO. May I ask how my self may be preserved so as to last?”
Kuang Ch’êng Tzŭ jumped up with a start. “A good question indeed!” cried he. “Come, and I will speak to you of perfect TAO.
“The essence of perfect TAO is profoundly mysterious; its extent is lost in obscurity.
“See nothing; hear nothing; let your soul be wrapped in quiet; and your body will begin to take proper form. Let there be absolute repose and absolute purity; do not weary your body nor disturb your vitality,—and you will live for ever. For if the eye sees nothing, and the ear hears nothing, and the mind