Module 0 · Orientation

How to read Seneca: sharpening and example

0.6

What you will learn

You know that Seneca writes rhetorically, with sharpened statements and examples from Rome, and how to read that for yourself.

Seneca is not a quiet writer. He claims, exaggerates, asks, exclaims. If you do not know this, you will read some things as a verdict that are meant as a nudge. This lesson shows you his tools, so that you recognise them when you meet them.

An orator writes

Seneca's father wrote about rhetoric, and Seneca himself became known as an orator before he was counted as a philosopher. You can tell from his prose. He writes the way one speaks before an audience: with short, sharp sentences, with repetitions, with questions to which he already knows the answer. This is not a flaw. It is his way of shaping a thought so that it lands.

For you this means: not every sentence is a statement of fact. Many sentences are sharpenings that say something true so pointedly that it catches the eye. If you take them literally as description, you will find Seneca unfair. If you read them as sharpening, you can examine what is true in them.

The sharpening

Here is an example from the seventh chapter. Seneca speaks of people whose time is occupied by other things, and judges them:

“No man knows less about living than a business man: there is nothing about which it is more difficult to gain knowledge.”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 7, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)

Taken literally, that is harsh. Can you deny that a person who can do a great deal and achieves a great deal knows how to live? We understand the sentence not as a verdict on a person, but as a distinction that Seneca sharpens so that it becomes visible: being able to do things and being able to live are not the same, and the second is not learned on the side. Stewart writes “business man”; you met this person in lesson 0.5 as one of the busy, a person something has taken possession of. Here he appears as a sharpening.

The example from Rome

Seneca loves examples, and he takes them from his world. In the fourth and fifth chapters he presents Augustus and Cicero, two of the most famous men of Rome, and shows how both longed for rest and did not find it. Of Augustus he writes that leisure was “the wish of him who could accomplish the wishes of all other men” (chapter 4). The example is meant to show: if not even the most powerful man in the world found time for himself, then it is not a matter of too little power.

Other examples are less kind. In the twelfth chapter Seneca describes men who spend hours at the barber's, tend their collections or have themselves carried about in litters, and he makes fun of them. His harshness towards the pleasure-seekers of his time is part of his style. We name it in this course, but we do not put it on show. What interests us in these passages is not the mockery, but the thought behind it: that busyness can look like leisure and yet not be leisure. Module 2 reads these chapters as a mirror, not as a caricature.

The question that wants no answer

Seneca asks a great deal. In the twelfth chapter, for example, about the men at the barber's:

“Do you call these men idle, who make a business of the comb and looking-glass?”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 12, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)

Stewart's “idle” here means at leisure, not lazy. Such questions want no answer. They want you to pause. Rhetoric calls this a rhetorical question; we understand it as an invitation to look at yourself. When you read such a question in this course, you do not have to answer it. It is enough to let it stand for a moment.

The image

And Seneca thinks in images. Life as riches that a bad master scatters. Time as a fast-running torrent from which you must drink quickly. Life poured into a vessel that cannot hold it, so that it leaks away through the chinks. And in the seventh chapter, the man at sea in a storm:

“such a man has not travelled much, he has only been much tossed about.”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 7, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)

An image does not say: This is how it is. It says: Look at it this way for once. You can take up an image or set it aside. You do not have to prove it.

How to read this for yourself

Three things help. First: when Seneca says “you”, he means Paulinus or an imagined opponent he is arguing with. You are not meant, unless you recognise yourself. Second: a sharpening is a magnifying glass, not a yardstick. It enlarges something so that you see it; it does not say how large it is in your life. Third: where Seneca judges, you may examine. At these points the course tells you: This is Seneca's claim. Then it is up to you.

Try it now: one sentence, three times

Here is a sentence from the first chapter:

“We do not have a very short time assigned to us, but we lose a great deal of it”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 1, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)
  1. Read the sentence once at your normal pace.
  2. Read it a second time, slowly, word by word. Notice which word stands out.
  3. Read it a third time and ask yourself: Where is the sharpening here, and what is the calm thought behind it?
  4. Write the calm thought in your own words in your notes, without exclamation marks.

Many people notice that the sentence grows quieter on the third reading. The orator steps back, the thought remains. That is the whole reading practice of this course in miniature: noticing Seneca's volume, and then hearing what he is actually saying.

In everyday life

Perhaps you know someone who likes to exaggerate when they want to tell you something important. “You're never at home”, they say, and they mean: I miss you. If you take the exaggeration literally, you argue about the word never. If you hear it as sharpening, you understand the sentence behind it. That is how you can read Seneca.

A moment of stillness

Take the calm thought from the practice with you into the next minute. Look up from the screen and let it be there, without volume.

To take with you

Seneca's sharpening is a magnifying glass, not a yardstick. It shows something large so that you see it.

Questions for reflection

  1. Which of Seneca's sentences in this lesson first sounded to you like a reproach, and what did you hear in it on the second reading?
  2. What is the calm thought you wrote down from the practice?