Module 7 · Fellow creatures

Why just these neighbours?

7.1

What you will learn

You understand how Thoreau observed animals, not as use or symbol but as neighbours, and why that belongs to attention.

Thoreau lived a mile from the nearest human being. But he did not live alone. Under his floor a mouse had its nest, past his door a partridge led her brood, on the pond a loon laughed. Thoreau called them his neighbours, and he meant the word.

“Why do precisely these objects which we behold make a world? Why has man just these species of animals for his neighbors; as if nothing but a mouse could have filled this crevice?”

Henry David Thoreau, Walden (1854), “Brute Neighbors”

So Thoreau opens the chapter “Brute Neighbors”. He does not answer his question. He lets it stand and adds only one thought: the writers of fables, “Pilpay & Co.”, have put animals to their best use, for in the fables all animals are “beasts of burden, in a sense, made to carry some portion of our thoughts”. Something like this: the fox stands for cunning, the ant for diligence, the dove for gentleness.

We understand Thoreau's remark about the fables as a quiet act of distancing. Thoreau knows how animals are used to say something about people. In this chapter, that is precisely what he does not do. He does not load a lesson onto the mouse's back. He looks at it.

The mouse

Thoreau writes that the mice in his house were not the common ones but a wild native kind, not found in the village. One of them already lived there before the house stood:

“When I was building, one of these had its nest underneath the house, and before I had laid the second floor, and swept out the shavings, would come out regularly at lunch time and pick up the crumbs at my feet. It probably had never seen a man before; and it soon became quite familiar, and would run over my shoes and up my clothes.”

Henry David Thoreau, Walden (1854), “Brute Neighbors”

One day, while Thoreau leaned with his elbow on the bench, it ran along his sleeve and round and round the paper which held his dinner. He kept the paper close and played at bopeep with it.

“When at last I held still a piece of cheese between my thumb and finger, it came and nibbled it, sitting in my hand, and afterward cleaned its face and paws, like a fly, and walked away.”

Henry David Thoreau, Walden (1854), “Brute Neighbors”

Notice how Thoreau tells it. He does not say what the mouse means. He says what it does: it comes at the same time, it eats, it runs over his shoes, it cleans itself like a fly and leaves. The closeness is not his achievement. He only held still, long enough.

The eye of the partridge

In June, Thoreau writes, the partridge, “which is so shy a bird”, led her brood first behind, then in front of his house, clucking and calling to them like a hen. The young resemble dried leaves so exactly that a traveller can place his foot in the midst of a brood without seeing them. Sometimes Thoreau held one of them in his open hand, and it squatted there, “obedient to their mother and their instinct”, without fear or trembling. Then he looks into their eyes:

“The remarkably adult yet innocent expression of their open and serene eyes is very memorable. All intelligence seems reflected in them. They suggest not merely the purity of infancy, but a wisdom clarified by experience. Such an eye was not born when the bird was, but is coeval with the sky it reflects.”

Henry David Thoreau, Walden (1854), “Brute Neighbors”

Remarkably adult yet innocent: that is the contradiction that holds Thoreau's gaze. A chick, a few days old, looks at him with an eye that is older than the bird. “The woods do not yield another such a gem,” he adds. And then, quite plainly: “These were my hens and chickens.”

We understand this passage as the heart of the chapter. Thoreau does not use the chick. He marvels at an eye that is of no use to him and explains nothing to him. The wonder is the whole gain.

Sitting still until the neighbours come

How do such encounters come about? Thoreau gives a simple answer in the same chapter. He describes a spring in the woods to which he went almost every day in midsummer, the woodcock who led her brood there, the turtle doves over the water, an inquisitive red squirrel on the nearest bough. And then:

“You only need sit still long enough in some attractive spot in the woods that all its inhabitants may exhibit themselves to you by turns.”

Henry David Thoreau, Walden (1854), “Brute Neighbors”

That is not a technique. It is the attitude you already know from this course: become still and wait for what shows itself. You remember the laughing loon from lesson 4.1, beside which Thoreau placed himself when he was asked about loneliness. Here, at the spring, the comparison becomes company: the animals come because he stays.

What this means for you

We understand this chapter as a widening of attention. In the last few modules you looked at yourself, at other people, at the water. Here attention goes one step further: to the living beings that live beside us without our usually noticing them. It does not end with humans.

We take three things from Thoreau's descriptions. First: wonder without use. The mouse brings nothing, the chick explains nothing, and yet both are a gem to Thoreau. Second: closeness without possession. The mouse comes and goes as it likes. Thoreau holds still, he does not hold on to it. Third: description instead of interpretation. What an animal does is interesting enough. It does not have to stand for something.

Thoreau's question, why just these animals are our neighbours, remains open. Perhaps it is not there to be answered. It is a way of looking: just this blackbird, just this dog, just this fly at the window make up the world you live in today.

What fellow creatures do not mean

First: no cuteness. Thoreau does not turn his neighbours into pets. In the same chapter he describes how hunters shoot the parent bird and the young fall a prey to some prowling beast. The world of his neighbours is beautiful and hard at the same time, and he looks at both.

Second: not animals as a mirror of human wishes. It is tempting to see in an animal what you yourself need at the moment: loyalty, freedom, calm. Thoreau resists exactly that. The eye of the partridge is not his eye. It is coeval with the sky and belongs to the bird.

Third: you do not have to touch or feed animals. The mouse came to Thoreau, not the other way round, and it came because he held still. Feeding wild animals is often not good for them. The closeness that matters here comes from attention, not from touch.

In everyday life

In the bathroom, in the corner above the shower, a spider has been sitting for a few days. Your first thought is to remove it. You leave it, not today. The next morning it is sitting in the same place, the morning after a hand's breadth further on. You begin to look while brushing your teeth, and you notice that it repairs its web at night. After a week you catch yourself greeting it in the morning. It has not changed. You have noticed a neighbour who was already there.

A related thought, elsewhere

In the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus says:

“Behold the fowls of the air: for they sow not, neither do they reap, nor gather into barns; yet your heavenly Father feedeth them. Are ye not much better than they?”

Matthew 6:26, King James Version

Behold the fowls of the air: here too a thought begins with someone looking at an animal that is of no use, and seeing something in it. And in the Dhammapada we read:

“All men tremble at punishment, all men love life; remember that thou art like unto them, and do not kill, nor cause slaughter.”

Dhammapada, verse 130, translated by F. Max Müller (1881)

The verse speaks of men. We understand it in this module one step further: all love life, the mouse as well as the human. Read in this way, it says what Thoreau did with his neighbours: recognise yourself in them, without making them into yourself.

A moment of stillness

Listen for a moment for another living being near you: a bird outside, a dog in the distance, an insect at the window. If you find one, stay with it for a few breaths. If not, notice that it is there anyway, somewhere.

To take with you

My neighbours are not only people. I only need to become still enough to notice them.

Questions for reflection

  1. Which animals are your neighbours without your usually noticing them?
  2. When did an animal last make you wonder, without being of any use to you?