Three chairs
5.1
What you will learn
You understand how Thoreau, who loved solitude, thought about company, and what it means to be really present with other people.
Thoreau is often remembered as a hermit. He was not. The chapter after “Solitude” is called “Visitors”, and it begins with a surprise.
“I think that I love society as much as most, and am ready enough to fasten myself like a bloodsucker for the time to any full-blooded man that comes in my way.”
Henry David Thoreau, Walden (1854), “Visitors”
The image is comic and a little grotesque, as Thoreau's images often are. But it says what he means: he loved people. He simply loved them in a different way.
One, two, three
“I had three chairs in my house; one for solitude, two for friendship, three for society.”
Henry David Thoreau, Walden (1854), “Visitors”
Three chairs, three ways of being. The first for being with oneself. The second for the closeness of a friend. The third for the company of many. When more visitors came, he writes, there was only the third chair for them all, “but they generally economized the room by standing up”.
We understand the three chairs as a simple map of a balanced life. Each chair has its own gift. Each can be too empty or too full.
Near and yet far apart
Thoreau was struck by how many people a small house could hold, and by something else:
“I have had twenty-five or thirty souls, with their bodies, at once under my roof, and yet we often parted without being aware that we had come very near to one another.”
Henry David Thoreau, Walden (1854), “Visitors”
The sentence is subtle: they may have come near to one another, and nobody noticed.
We understand this sentence as the core of this theme. We can be in the same room with people, even with people we love, and not really meet them. Being present with others means being awake to them: seeing the person in front of us, hearing what they say, noticing what they do not say.
Winnowed
A man living alone in the woods has few visitors, you would think. Thoreau saw it differently:
“I had more visitors while I lived in the woods than at any other period in my life; I mean that I had some. I met several there under more favorable circumstances than I could any where else. But fewer came to see me on trivial business. In this respect, my company was winnowed by my mere distance from town.”
Henry David Thoreau, Walden (1854), “Visitors”
The little afterthought, “I mean that I had some”, is a joke at his own expense. The thought behind it is serious. Someone who lives a mile from the village gets no visits out of boredom. Whoever came had taken a walk to get there, and that changed the meeting. The distance, he writes, worked like a sieve: the casual was held back, and “only the finest sediment was deposited around me”.
We understand this not as advice to move away from people. It is an observation about what makes meetings good: not their number, but that both people want to be there.
The woodchopper
Whom did Thoreau meet under such favourable circumstances? The longest passage in the chapter “Visitors” belongs to no poet and no scholar, but to a Canadian woodchopper, “a Canadian, a woodchopper and post-maker, who can hole fifty posts in a day”. Thoreau does not give his name. Historians believe that it was Alek Therien, a day labourer from the Concord area with whom Thoreau remained friendly for years.
Thoreau describes this man at length. How he came strolling across the bean-field in the morning, without haste. How he sat on a log at noon and chickadees alighted on his arm. How he laughed when a thought pleased him, and sometimes rolled on the ground with laughter.
“A more simple and natural man it would be hard to find.”
Henry David Thoreau, Walden (1854), “Visitors”
Thoreau writes that his only books were “an almanac and an arithmetic”, and that he knew the arithmetic very well indeed. What interested Thoreau about him, he says himself: “because he was so quiet and solitary and so happy withal”. And he admits that he could not make the man out: he did not know “whether he was as wise as Shakespeare or as simply ignorant as a child”.
We understand this portrait as a lesson in how to look at a person. Thoreau, who had studied at Harvard, does not measure the woodchopper by origin, education or standing. He looks for a long time, lets himself be surprised, and lets him remain a puzzle. Of such people, he writes a little later, there may be “men of genius in the lowest grades of life, however permanently humble and illiterate, … who are as bottomless even as Walden Pond was thought to be, though they may be dark and muddy”.
Thoreau's hardness
The same Thoreau could be harsh. Of people who came with urgent requests and at the same time declared that they were resolved never to help themselves, he writes:
“I require of a visitor that he be not actually starving, though he may have the very best appetite in the world, however he got it. Objects of charity are not guests.”
Henry David Thoreau, Walden (1854), “Visitors”
This is Thoreau's claim. The last sentence is cold. This course does not teach it. We read it as the boundary of a man who kept his house open for meeting and not for demands, and as a reminder that even a good observer has his blind spots.
And yet, in the same chapter, a single sentence, almost in passing: “One real runaway slave, among the rest, whom I helped to forward toward the northstar.” Historians believe that the Thoreau family in Concord more than once helped people fleeing slavery on their way to Canada. Where it mattered, the door was open.
Presence, not quantity
Thoreau's solitude was not a rejection of people. It was what made his company possible. Someone who can be alone does not need others to fill an emptiness, and can therefore meet them more freely. We understand the two themes as one: the first chair prepares the second and the third.
What this does not mean
It does not mean having as many people around you as possible. Thoreau did not count his visitors, he looked at them. A full calendar is not a full third chair.
It does not mean demanding depth of every encounter. A greeting at the checkout may remain a greeting. Presence means being where you are, not turning everything into a conversation about life.
And it does not mean that solitude is better than company. Thoreau had three chairs, not one. The first was dear to him, but he did not set it above the other two.
In everyday life
You have dinner with an old friend. Afterwards you realise that you talked for two hours, mostly about other people, about plans, about news. It was lovely. And yet you are not sure what is really going on in your friend's life right now. You came near to one another, and you did not quite meet.
A related thought, elsewhere
In the book of the Chinese sage Zhuangzi, the author has Confucius teach a disciple how to listen in earnest:
“You hear not with the ears, but with the mind; not with the mind, but with your soul.”
Zhuangzi, chapter IV, translated by Herbert A. Giles (1889)
How we listen shapes what we receive. In its own way the sentence says that a person is only fully heard when we take in more than the words.
A moment of stillness
Think of one person you will see in the coming days. Picture their face for a moment, as clearly as you can. Notice what it would mean to really meet them next time.
To take with you
We can sit under one roof and never come near. Presence is what brings us close.
Questions for reflection
- Which of the three chairs is fullest in your life right now? Which is emptiest?
- With whom do you come near, and whom do you only meet?