The good in you
8.1
What you will learn
You know the sermon on good and evil: you are good when you are one with yourself; when you are not, you are not evil, for a divided house is not a den of thieves.
One of the elders of the city asks Almustafa to speak of good and evil. People expect a teaching: what is allowed and what is not. Almustafa gives none. In his first sentence he says that he can speak of only one of the two.
Of the good, not of the evil
“Of the good in you I can speak, but not of the evil. For what is evil but good tortured by its own hunger and thirst?”
Kahlil Gibran, The Prophet (1923), On Good and Evil
Gibran writes something unusual here. For him, evil is not a force of its own that stands against the good. It is the good itself, when it is hungry and thirsty. When the good is hungry, he goes on, it will look for food even in dark caves, and when it is thirsty, it will drink even from dead water. This is Gibran's claim. What we call evil would then be a lack, not a being. Someone who does wrong is a person whose good has eaten something wrong because it was hungry.
We understand this not as an excuse for everything; lesson 8.2 deals with crime. Here the point is how we look. If you see evil as a foreign power, all you can do is fight it. If you see it as hungry good, you can ask what it lacks.
One with yourself
“You are good when you are one with yourself.”
Kahlil Gibran, The Prophet (1923), On Good and Evil
“Yet when you are not one with yourself you are not evil. For a divided house is not a den of thieves; it is only a divided house. And a ship without rudder may wander aimlessly among perilous isles yet sink not to the bottom.”
Kahlil Gibran, The Prophet (1923), On Good and Evil
The first sentence is on your map for the eighth theme. It is Gibran's whole answer to the question of what is good: to be one with yourself. Not to follow a rule. To be one. If you have reconciled the two guests from module 7, you are good in Gibran's sense.
The second sentence is the gentler one, and it is the more important one. If you are not one with yourself, you are not evil. The divided house, where the head wants one thing and the heart another, is not a den of thieves. And the ship without rudder from lesson 7.2 wanders, but it does not sink. We understand this as the central sentence of the module. In Gibran, there is a wide country between good and evil, and most of us live there, most of the time. It is not a bad place. It is just not yet the whole.
Good in countless ways
Then comes a series of sentences in the same pattern, which we give in our own words. You are good when you give of yourself; you are not evil when you seek gain for yourself, for then you are like a root that clings to the earth, and the fruit cannot tell the root to be as giving as it is. You are good when you are wide awake as you speak; you are not evil when your tongue stumbles. You are good when you walk with firm steps towards your goal; you are not evil when you go there limping. Someone who limps, Gibran says, is still not going backwards.
Two sentences stand out. One warns the strong not to limp in front of the lame and call it kindness. The other sums everything up: you are good in countless ways, and you are not evil when you are not good. You are then only loitering and sluggish.
Gibran uses the language of his time here. We understand the limping as an image for any progress that is slower than we would like, not as a statement about people with a disability.
The longing for your giant self
“In your longing for your giant self lies your goodness: and that longing is in all of you.”
Kahlil Gibran, The Prophet (1923), On Good and Evil
Here Gibran says where the good lives. Not in the deed, but in the longing. And the longing is in everyone: in some it is a torrent, in others a flat stream that loses itself in turns and windings. But the one who longs much should not ask the one who longs little why he is so slow. And then comes the sentence with which the sermon ends:
“For the truly good ask not the naked, “Where is your garment?” nor the houseless, “What has befallen your house?””
Kahlil Gibran, The Prophet (1923), On Good and Evil
We understand this sentence as the touchstone for the whole module. The question about the garment is a judgement in the form of a question. The truly good do not ask it. They see that someone is cold, and that is enough. This is how Gibran recognises the good: not by whether someone does the right thing, but by how they look at the one who did not.
The giant self
In this sermon Gibran speaks of “your giant self”; you met the phrase in lesson 0.5. We understand it as what you could be if you were wholly one with yourself: larger than who you are today, but not a stranger. For Gibran, the longing for it is goodness itself. That is his view, not a fact.
Not meant: a better self you have to earn, or an ideal you fail to live up to. The longing already is the goodness, not only its fulfilment.
What “the good in you” does not mean
Three misunderstandings suggest themselves. Gibran does not say there is no wrong. The next sermon is about crime and punishment. Nor does he say that everything is excused because evil is only hungry good. Whoever harms you harms you, and you may protect yourself; lesson 8.4 is about that. And he does not say that you have to feel good in order to be good. The divided house is expressly not a den of thieves.
In everyday life
In the morning you snap at someone who did not deserve it. All morning you think: I am a bad person. We understand Gibran like this: No. You are a divided house. Something in you was hungry, for sleep perhaps, or for quiet, and it ate in the wrong place. That does not make the apology unnecessary. But it is easier to say when you do not have to be a thief to say it.
A moment of stillness
Think of something you did not do well today. Say to yourself quietly: A divided house, not a den of thieves. Stay with it for one breath.
To take with you
I am good when I am one with myself. When I am not, I am not evil, only a divided house.
Questions for reflection
- When did you last ask the question about the garment, of others or of yourself?
- What is hungry in you right now, and where is it eating in the wrong place?