The soul unfolds itself like a lotus
7.1
What you will learn
You know the sermon on self-knowledge: say not, I have found the truth, but a truth; and the soul like a lotus of countless petals.
With this module the third movement of the course begins. After being together and living day by day, the path turns inward. A man from the crowd asks Almustafa to speak of self-knowledge. The answer is one of the shortest sermons in the book. It ends with the image you know from the map.
What the heart already knows
“Your hearts know in silence the secrets of the days and the nights. But your ears thirst for the sound of your heart’s knowledge. You would know in words that which you have always known in thought.”
Kahlil Gibran, The Prophet (1923), On Self-Knowledge
Gibran writes nothing here about having to search for yourself. He writes that your heart already knows. What is missing is not the knowledge but the sound: you want to hear it, in words. Gibran has Almustafa add that this is as it should be. The hidden wellspring of the soul, he says, must rise and run murmuring to the sea. So for him the need to understand yourself is no fault. It is part of being human.
We understand this passage as a reversal of the usual direction. We usually think of self-knowledge as a journey towards something we do not yet have. Gibran says: it is there, in thought, in silence. The words come afterwards. So the question of this module is not: Who could I be? But: What do I already know when I grow still?
No scales, no sounding line
“But let there be no scales to weigh your unknown treasure; And seek not the depths of your knowledge with staff or sounding line. For self is a sea boundless and measureless.”
Kahlil Gibran, The Prophet (1923), On Self-Knowledge
A sounding line is a rope with a weight on the end, which sailors use to measure the depth of the water. Gibran names two tools, the scales and the sounding line, and says: not here. What you find in yourself cannot be weighed and cannot be plumbed. This is Gibran's claim. For him the self is not an object with edges and a floor, but a sea.
The image speaks into a time that likes to measure: tests that sum up your personality in letters, questionnaires with scores. None of that is wrong. Gibran only reminds us that the result is not you. The sounding line measures one spot. The sea remains larger.
A truth
“Say not, “I have found the truth,” but rather, “I have found a truth.” Say not, “I have found the path of the soul.” Say rather, “I have met the soul walking upon my path.” For the soul walks upon all paths.”
Kahlil Gibran, The Prophet (1923), On Self-Knowledge
The whole difference lies in one small word. The truth, or a truth. The path, or my path. Gibran writes against the idea that there is a single right way for the soul, which you can find and then possess. Whoever has found a truth can let others stand beside them who have found a different one. Whoever has found the truth has to defend it.
We understand the second sentence as the quieter one. You do not find the path of the soul like a road on a map. You walk your own way and meet the soul there, for it was already on its way, on all paths. You do not have to find the right way. You have to be attentive on your way.
Line, reed, lotus
“The soul walks not upon a line, neither does it grow like a reed.”
Kahlil Gibran, The Prophet (1923), On Self-Knowledge
“The soul unfolds itself, like a lotus of countless petals.”
Kahlil Gibran, The Prophet (1923), On Self-Knowledge
Three images, one contrast. The line is the straight way from here to there: a plan, a career, a goal. The reed grows upward, in one direction. Both are images of growth as we usually imagine it: forward, upward, measurable. The lotus grows differently. It opens from the centre outward, in every direction, one petal after another, and there are countless of them.
The lotus is rooted in mud and opens its blossom above the water. Gibran does not explain the image. He places it at the end of the sermon and lets it stand. We understand it like this: knowing yourself does not mean arriving at a goal. It means unfolding, slowly, in every direction. Each petal that opens is a part of you that you had not seen before. And there is no last petal. This sentence stands on your map for the seventh theme.
Soul and self
In this sermon Gibran speaks of the soul that walks upon all paths and of the self that is a sea. In lesson 0.5 you read how he uses these words, and in lesson 0.1 that he speaks in a language of his own, between Christian, Sufi and Romantic traditions, without making a doctrine of it. We understand soul here as what is alive and moving in you, and self as the whole breadth of what you are, including what you do not yet know. Both are Gibran's view. You do not have to share it to use the image.
Not meant: the soul as the doctrine of a religion; the self as a personality profile that you determine once and then know.
What self-knowledge does not mean in Gibran
Three misunderstandings suggest themselves. Self-knowledge in Gibran does not mean thinking about yourself endlessly. The sermon ends with a flower, not with an analysis. Nor does it mean finding the one answer to who you are: no scales, no sounding line, only a truth. And it does not mean revolving around yourself. Almustafa is speaking to a crowd. The soul walks upon all paths, including those of other people.
In everyday life
You tell a friend about a decision you have not yet made. You lay out both sides as if you were undecided. And while you are talking, you hear in your own voice that you have known for a long time what you want. Your friend only listened. That is what Gibran means: your heart knew it in silence. Your ears wanted to hear it.
A moment of stillness
Rest your hands in your lap and ask yourself quietly: What do I already know right now, without saying it out loud? Wait one breath for an answer. None has to come.
To take with you
My heart already knows in silence. What I find is a truth, not the truth.
Questions for reflection
- When did you last learn something about yourself that you actually already knew?
- Which truth about yourself do you currently hold to be the truth, and what would change if it were only a truth?