Restless pleasure
7.1
What you will learn
You know Seneca's thought that even the pleasures of the busy are restless, because they fear their end (chapter 17, first half).
Up to this point Seneca has written about people who have no time. In this module he looks at their good hours: at the feasts, the successes, the wishes fulfilled. And he finds no peace there either.
A word of care. This module is about wishes, ambition and the fear of the end. Seneca also speaks about death, soberly and as a thought about the limits of time, never as a goal. If this touches you right now, because you are grieving or going through something hard, read at your own pace and skip what is too much. This course is a philosophical practice. It is no substitute for therapy or medical treatment. If something moves you deeply, turn to a professional or to a person you trust.
How long will this last?
“Such men’s very pleasures are restless and disturbed by various alarms, and at the most joyous moment of all there rises the anxious thought: “How long will this last?””
Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 17, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)
Seneca writes here about the same people as in the modules before: the busy. But he changes the direction of his gaze. Until now it was about the hours they give away to others. Now it is about the hours they keep for themselves, about their pleasures. His finding: these are not free either. In the middle of the pleasure a voice speaks up and asks how much longer this can go well. The title takes its word from this passage: the pleasures are “restless”, and a little later Seneca says that even the joys by which the busy raise themselves above others are “of a mixed character”. The joy is there. But something lies over it.
The weeping king
Seneca gives an example his readers knew:
“That most arrogant Persian king, when his army stretched over vast plains and could not be counted but only measured, burst into tears at the thought that in less than a hundred years none of all those warriors would be alive”
Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 17, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)
It is assumed that Xerxes is meant, the Persian king. A man stands at the height of his power, looks at an army that can no longer be counted, only measured, and weeps. Not for joy. Out of fear of an end that lies a hundred years away.
Then comes Seneca's turn:
“yet their death was brought upon them by the very man who wept over it, who was about to destroy some of them by sea, some on land, some in battle, and some in flight, and who would in a very short space of time put an end to those about whose hundredth year he showed such solicitude.”
Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 17, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)
We understand the passage like this: grief over transience changes nothing as long as it remains only a mood. Xerxes weeps over the end of his soldiers and leads them into war. The thought of the end has not made him calmer, it has only spoiled his joy. This is a sharpening of the kind you know from lesson 0.6. Seneca looks for the biggest example so that the pattern becomes visible. It holds on a small scale too.
Joys without solid ground
Where does this restlessness in the middle of good fortune come from? Seneca answers that the joys of the busy “do not rest upon any solid grounds, but are disturbed by the same emptiness from which they spring”. Then comes the sentence around which this module turns:
“All the greatest blessings are enjoyed with fear, and no thing is so untrustworthy as extreme prosperity: we require fresh strokes of good fortune to enable us to keep that which we are enjoying, and even those of our prayers which are answered require fresh prayers.”
Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 17, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)
This is Seneca's claim. Joys that come from outside, from chance, from success, from possessions, have no ground. Whoever has them must guard them. Whoever guards them needs more of them to secure what is guarded. That is how a chain arises: an answered prayer calls for the next one. Not because people are greedy, but because what they have gained does not carry them.
We understand this not as a verdict on joy. Seneca describes what happens to a joy that depends entirely on something you can lose: it tips over into worry. His question to you is: What does your joy depend on? On something that lasts, or on something that threatens to fall?
Gaining and holding
“they obtain what they wish with infinite labour, and they hold what they have obtained with fear and trembling. Meanwhile they take no account of time, of which they will never have a fresh and larger supply”
Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 17, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)
You know this sentence from the map in lesson 0.7. There are two movements in it: obtaining with labour and holding with fear. Both cost time, and that time does not come back. Seneca does not say that these people achieve nothing. They achieve a great deal. It is just that they do not live while doing it. You read the second half of the chapter, in which one ambition gives birth to the next, in lesson 4.2. Here the question is what drives us.
Pleasure and ambition
In Stewart's English, “pleasures” and “joys” are the pleasant sides of the busy life in Seneca: feasts, possessions, success, standing. “Ambition” is the striving for office and fame. In chapter 2 Seneca speaks of “an ambition which makes him court the good will of others”. Read this way, ambition is a dependence on the judgement of others. We understand pleasure and ambition in Seneca as two forms of the same restlessness.
Not meant: that joy is suspect, or that you may not achieve anything. What is meant is the joy that brings fear, and the striving without end.
What restless pleasure does not mean
Three misunderstandings are close at hand. Seneca does not say that joy as such is bad. He himself lived richly, at court; lesson 0.2 spoke of this. Nor does he say that you should give up everything. Renunciation can be just as anxious as possession. And he does not say that the fear of the end is a weakness. For him it is a sign that the joy rests on something that does not carry it.
In everyday life
The third day of your holiday. The weather is good, the food too, and in the middle of a lovely afternoon you count: four more days. The thought is quiet, but it settles over the afternoon. You are still there, and inside you are already saying goodbye. That is human. Seneca does not want to talk you out of it. He wants you to notice it.
A related thought: Letter to Lucilius
You know from lesson 3.1 the sentence from Letter 1 in which Seneca, years later, writes to Lucilius that everything belongs to others and only time is ours. We understand this sentence as the key to chapter 17. If everything we gain belongs to others, it is clear why we hold it with fear: it was never fully ours. Only time belongs to us, and that is exactly what the busy take no account of. In module 9 you will return to this letter.
A moment of stillness
Think of something you are looking forward to at the moment. Stay with the joy for one breath. Then check quietly whether a small worry has come along too. You do not have to push it away. Only notice it.
To take with you
A joy I have to hold on to makes me afraid. Seneca asks what my joy depends on.
Questions for reflection
- Where do you know this: in the middle of something lovely, the question of how long it will last?
- Which of your wishes, once fulfilled, immediately woke a new wish?