Module 6 · The company of the wise

Only the wise really live

6.1

What you will learn

You know Seneca's thought that the centuries are open to those who devote themselves to philosophy, and that you can let yourself be adopted by the wise (chapters 14 and 15).

Who do you spend your time with? The question sounds like it is about people: family, colleagues, friends. Seneca asks it more widely. For him, the company you live in also includes the company you think with: the voices you read, listen to, carry with you. And he claims that you can choose this company, across the centuries.

“The only persons who are really at leisure are those who devote themselves to philosophy: and they alone really live: for they do not merely enjoy their own lifetime, but they annex every century to their own: all the years which have passed before them belong to them.”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 14, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)

This is how chapter 14 begins, and it is a bold sentence. Only those who devote themselves to philosophy really live. This is Seneca's claim, and it sounds exclusive. Before you reject it, read how he justifies it. These people do not only keep their own lifetime, as the previous modules described. They add something to it: they “annex every century to their own”. Everything that was thought and made before them becomes their possession. Their life does not grow longer because they have more years, but because they are at home in more years.

Not shut out from any period

How is that supposed to work? Seneca describes it as a journey:

“we are not shut out from any period, we can make our way into every subject, and, if only we can summon up sufficient strength of mind to overstep the narrow limit of human weakness, we have a vast extent of time wherein to disport ourselves: we may argue with Socrates, doubt with Carneades, repose with Epicurus, overcome human nature with the Stoics, out-herod it with the Cynics.”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 14, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)

The list is remarkable. Seneca was a Stoic, and yet he names Socrates, the doubter Carneades and the Cynics in one breath. And Epicurus, who belonged to a different tradition and whom Seneca, as you know from the opening module, likes to quote. He does not say: read the right ones. He says: the centuries are open, go in. We understand this as one of the most generous passages in the whole work. Whoever reads leaves the limits of their own time. They can talk with people who died centuries ago, and those people answer, because they wrote.

You are doing this right now. Seneca has been dead for almost two thousand years, and you are in conversation with him.

Choosing your parents

In chapter 15 Seneca goes one step further. He takes up a sentence people said then as they do today: you cannot choose your parents.

“We are wont to say that we are not able to choose who our parents should be, but that they were assigned to us by chance; yet we may be born just as we please: there are several families of the noblest intellects: choose which you would like to belong to: by your adoption you will not receive their name only, but also their property, which is not intended to be guarded in a mean and miserly spirit: the more persons you divide it among the larger it becomes.”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 15, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)

This is the image of adoption. Seneca is thinking of being taken into a family in which, as he says himself, the name is passed on. And he says: there are families of the mind, and you can let yourself be taken into them. No one asks where you come from. You choose whom you want to belong to, and you receive not only the name, but “also their property”. And this possession, unlike money, does not grow smaller when you share it. Seneca says: “the more persons you divide it among the larger it becomes”.

We understand this thought as the centre of the module. You did not choose where you come from. The voices you think with, you can choose. The voices around you are mostly just there: in the family, at work, on the phone. Seneca invites you to make the choice consciously.

What philosophy preserves

Why should you let yourself be taken into these families in particular? Seneca compares their possession with what ambition leaves behind:

“High office, monuments, all that ambition records in decrees or piles up in stone, soon passes away: lapse of time casts down and ruins everything; but those things on which Philosophy has set its seal are beyond the reach of injury”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 15, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)

That is a bold claim, and you can test it. Much of what stood as an honour or a monument in Seneca's time has disappeared. His letter to Paulinus lies before you. What Philosophy “has set its seal” on has in fact been handed down, from hand to hand, all the way into this course. That does not prove Seneca right. It shows what he cares about: there are possessions that decay with time, and possessions that grow with it.

Eternity and immortality

In two places Seneca goes beyond what a course about time can test. In chapter 14 he asks why we do not give ourselves up with our whole mind “to what is vast, what is eternal”, and in chapter 15 he writes of the wise:

“These will open to you the path which leads to eternity, and will raise you to a height from whence none shall cast you down. By this means alone can you prolong your mortal life, nay, even turn it into an immortal one.”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 15, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)

Here the Stoic is speaking. Seneca assumes that through reason a human being shares in something that reaches beyond them, and that philosophy gives them a share in it. This is Seneca's claim, carried by his philosophy, and this course does not teach it as fact. You do not have to believe anything about eternity in order to use the image of adoption. What remains even without this view is more modest and still a great deal: whoever thinks with the wise lives in more time than their own.

In everyday life

A man who hears voices all day at work that push, compare, judge, reads for twenty minutes in the evening in a book that was written a hundred years ago. He notices that the voice in the book speaks to him differently from the ones at work. More calmly, without wanting anything. After a few weeks it strikes him that during the day he sometimes thinks in that voice. Without calling it that, he has let himself be taken into a family.

What the company of the wise does not mean

Three misunderstandings are close at hand. First: Seneca does not mean that only scholars live. His “philosophy” is not knowledge, but the art of living that chapter 7 speaks of, where he says that “one’s whole life must be spent in learning how to live”. Whoever engages seriously with a single book belongs. Whoever wants to know how many rowers Ulysses had does not necessarily belong, as chapter 13 showed in module 2. Second: it is not about trading the people around you for books. The company of the wise is an addition, not a replacement for those sitting next to you. Third: the sentence that only the wise really live is Seneca's sharpening. He does not want to declare everyone else dead. He wants to say that life grows to the extent that you share it with the best voices.

A word of care. At the beginning of chapter 15 Seneca writes: “None of these men will force you to die, but all of them will teach you how to die”. This is a thought about the limits of time, as it often returns in Seneca: whoever knows that life ends lives it differently. It is not a goal and not a demand. If the subject weighs on you, go gently with it and talk to a person you trust.

A moment of stillness

Think of a voice that has made you wiser or calmer in your life. A person, a book, a teacher. Feel for a moment that this voice belongs to your family.

To take with you

I did not choose where I come from. The voices I think with, I can choose.

Questions for reflection

  1. Which voices are you in conversation with most at the moment?
  2. Which family of the mind would you let yourself be taken into, if you could choose?
  3. What of the things you possess grows when you share it?