Module 5 · Three times

Past, present, future

5.1

What you will learn

You know how Seneca divides life into three times, and his thought that only the past is certain, because no one can take it from you any more (chapter 10).

Where are you right now? Not in space, but in time. Perhaps in a conversation from yesterday that keeps following you. Perhaps at an appointment tomorrow that unsettles you. Perhaps, for a moment, here. In chapter 10 Seneca gives the division with which this question can be answered, and he gives it right after a sentence that changes his stance towards the busy.

“Yet, in order that sinners may be confronted with their errors, they must be taught, and not merely mourned for.”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 10, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)

Up to this point Seneca has described the busy, held up a mirror to them, sharpened the picture. Now he wants to explain. In Stewart's English they are called “sinners” here, and the point is the same: they are to be taught, not just lamented. And the explanation begins with a division so simple that it is easy to read past:

“Life is divided into three parts: that which has been, that which is, and that which is to come: of these three stages, that which we are passing through is brief, that which we are about to pass is uncertain, and that which we have passed is certain: this it is over which Fortune has lost her rights, and which can fall into no other man’s power”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 10, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)

Three times, three qualities. The present is brief. The future is uncertain. The past is certain. Seneca writes this not as a mood, but as a finding. And the surprising part lies in the third of these: the past is the only time that is safe. Not the future, on which we place everything, as you saw in module 4. Not the present, which can hardly be grasped. But what has already happened.

What no one can take any more

Why is the past safe? Because Fortune “has lost her rights” over it. What was yesterday cannot turn out differently tomorrow. No misfortune, no illness, no person can change it. Seneca heightens this into an image:

“yet this is a holy and consecrated part of our time, beyond the reach of all human accidents, removed from the dominion of Fortune, and which cannot be disquieted by want, fear, or attacks of sickness: this can neither be troubled nor taken away from one: we possess it for ever undisturbed.”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 10, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)

Everything we fear about the future can no longer touch the past. A good day you have lived is lived. It stays with you, whatever comes. This is Seneca's claim, and we understand it as a reversal of the usual view. Mostly we look at the past as what is over, and at the future as what we still have. Seneca turns it around: the future you do not have. The past you have.

A possession you can enter

But only, Seneca adds, if you look at it:

“Our present consists only of single days, and those, too, taken one hour at a time: but all the days of past times appear before us when bidden, and allow themselves to be examined and lingered over, albeit busy men cannot find time for so doing.”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 10, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)

The days of the past appear “when bidden”. You can call them up, examine them, linger over them. For Seneca this is a wealth that grows the longer you live, and grows the more often you look at it. The busy have it too, but they do not enter it, because they lack the time. And sometimes, Seneca says, it is not only time that is lacking:

“No one, unless all his acts have been submitted to the infallible censorship of his own conscience, willingly turns his thoughts back upon the past.”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 10, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)

Whoever looks back meets what he has done. For someone who has spent his life hiding from himself, that is uncomfortable. Seneca describes how the busy “take no pleasure in remembering what they regret” and are therefore “unwilling” to turn their minds back. We understand this not as a reproach, but as an observation: the safe possession of the past is open only to someone who can bear to look at it. That makes self-examination in Seneca something other than a punishment. It is the key to a room that otherwise stays locked.

The yoke and the leaking vessel

For those who cannot look back, Seneca finds two images:

“It is the privilege of a tranquil and peaceful mind to review all the parts of its life: but the minds of busy men are like animals under the yoke, and cannot bend aside or look back. Consequently, their life passes away into vacancy, and as you do no good however much you may pour into a vessel which cannot keep or hold what you put there, so also it matters not how much time you give men if it can find no place to settle in, but leaks away through the chinks and holes of their minds.”

Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 10, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)

The yoke: a draught animal that can only go forward. The vessel: a life into which years are poured and which holds none of them. Whoever lives only forward loses what lies behind, because it finds no place to settle. In Seneca, memory is the place where what has been lived can settle and stay.

A related thought: Letter to Lucilius

In Letter 1 to Lucilius, Seneca writes about the past in a different tone:

“For this is where we are mistaken: we look ahead to death, but a great part of it has already passed; whatever part of our life lies behind us, death holds.”

Seneca, Letters to Lucilius, Letter 1, section 2. Our translation from the Latin

That sounds like the opposite of chapter 10. There the past is a safe possession, here death holds it. We understand both as two sides of the same thought. The past is closed. No one can take it any more, and no one can change it any more. Whether that sounds comforting or serious depends on what you have put into it. That is why looking back is worthwhile, and why it is worthwhile to put something into it today.

In everyday life

A woman is clearing out her late mother's flat and finds photos of a summer at a lake that she had hardly remembered. She sits down on the floor and stays for an hour. Nothing about that summer can be taken from her any more. It was, and it remains. That is what Seneca means when he calls the past “certain”. And the fact that she had almost forgotten the summer shows how rarely we enter this possession while the day keeps driving us on.

What the three times do not mean in Seneca

First: Seneca does not say that you should live in the past. He says that you can possess it. Whoever only looks back loses the present, which, as he will soon say, is the only time left to the busy, and even that barely. Second: the self-examination he speaks of is not self-condemnation. It makes the past a place you can enter, because you no longer need to be afraid in it. Third: the sentence that the past is safe is not a consolation for every loss. Something hard that has happened remains hard. Seneca speaks of what you have lived, not of everything past having been good.

A word of care. Seneca's sentence from the letter, that death holds what lies behind us, is a thought about the limits of time. It is not meant to frighten, and it is not a goal. If looking back brings you to loss, to grief or to something that does not heal, go gently. You do not have to experience the past as a possession in order to continue with this module. And if the memory becomes too heavy, a person you trust or a professional is the right place for it.

A moment of stillness

Call to mind one single good day from your life. Any day. Stay with it for a moment. No one can take it from you.

To take with you

The future I do not have. The present I barely have. The past I have, when I look at it.

Questions for reflection

  1. Which of the three times are you in most often at the moment?
  2. Is there a part of your past that you like to enter, and one that you avoid?
  3. What does it mean to you that no one can take a lived day from you any more?