Life is not short
1.1
What you will learn
You know Seneca's basic thought: life is long enough if it is used in full (chapter 1).
Almost everyone knows the sigh that life is too short. Seneca begins his work with exactly this complaint. He repeats it as if he shared it. Then he contradicts it.
The complaint everyone knows
“The greater part of mankind, my Paulinus, complains of the unkindness of Nature, because we are born only for a short space of time, and that this allotted period of life runs away so swiftly, nay so hurriedly”
Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 1, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)
That is the first sentence. Seneca is writing to a man with a great deal to do, and he meets him at something every busy person knows: the feeling that the years pass faster than you can keep up with them. He gives examples to show that it is not only the crowd who complain like this, but respected men too. He recalls the well-known saying of physicians “that art is long but life is short”. It is assumed that it goes back to Hippocrates. And he reminds us of Aristotle, who quarrelled with Nature because she gives some animals centuries and man so little.
Seneca takes the complaint seriously. He does not laugh at it. But he does not let it stand.
Seneca's contradiction
“We do not have a very short time assigned to us, but we lose a great deal of it: life is long enough to carry out the most important projects: we have an ample portion, if we do but arrange the whole of it aright”
Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 1, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)
Seneca writes here the sentence that carries the whole book. Time is not scarce. It is ample. What seems scarce is what we leave of it after we have scattered it. A few lines further on he sums it up once more:
“Thus it is: we do not receive a short life, but we make it a short one, and we are not poor in days, but wasteful of them.”
Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 1, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)
This is Seneca's claim. It is a bold one, and it cannot be proved. No one can measure whether a life was long enough. Seneca knows this. He proves nothing, he turns your gaze. As long as I believe that Nature has given me too little, I can do nothing but complain. As soon as I assume that the time is there and I just do not see it, I have something to work with.
We understand the sentence like this: it is not a statement about the length of a life in years. It is a statement about where we look. Whoever complains about shortness is looking at the end. Whoever asks where the time goes is looking at the days.
The wise guardian
Seneca loves comparisons from the world of property, and the first comes in the very first chapter:
“When great and kinglike riches fall into the hands of a bad master, they are dispersed straightway, but even a moderate fortune, when bestowed upon a wise guardian, increases by use: and in like manner our life has great opportunities for one who knows how to dispose of it to the best advantage.”
Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 1, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)
The image is simple. A large inheritance can vanish in a short time, a small fortune can grow in good hands. What decides is not the sum, but how it is handled. Seneca was very rich himself; you read that in the opening module.
Applied to life: it is not the number of years that decides, but what happens with them. How Seneca imagines this is something he unfolds in the following chapters, and this course follows him module by module.
Long enough, if you know how to use it
At the beginning of the second chapter Seneca takes up the thought once more and gives it the form that returns again and again in this course:
“Why do we complain of Nature? she has dealt kindly with us. Life is long enough, if you know how to use it.”
Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 2, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)
You have already read this sentence in the opening module, and you will read it again at the end of the course. It is the leitmotif. Everything Seneca describes after it, the busy, the people asking for your time, the putting off, the three times, is an answer to the question of what it means to know how to use life.
In the same chapter there is a second sentence that belongs with it. Seneca quotes a poet who says that we live only a small part of our lives, and adds:
“But all duration is time, not life”
Seneca, Of the Shortness of Life, chapter 2, trans. Aubrey Stewart (1889)
Here Seneca separates two words that we hardly tell apart in everyday life: life and time. In lesson 0.5 you met the Latin terms vita and tempus. Time passes in any case. Life, according to Seneca, is only the part of time that belongs to us; the rest of the span is merely duration, merely time. The question of this module is therefore not: How many years do I have left? It is: How much of my time so far has been life?
Long enough
Seneca does not say that life is long. He says it is long enough, and he ties that to a condition: if it is used well. Long enough is therefore not a measure in years, but a relation between the time that is there and what a person does with it. We understand the phrase in this course as an invitation to turn the calculation around: not to ask how much is missing, but how much was already there.
Not meant: that every life is objectively long enough, even one cut off early. Seneca is writing to an adult with many years of experience, and he is writing about how we deal with time, not about fate.
In everyday life
It is Sunday evening. You look back on the week and can hardly find it. Monday to Friday are a single block of appointments, messages and errands, Saturday went on shopping and laundry, Sunday is almost over. You say to yourself: The week was far too short. Seneca would ask: Was it short, or did it just not belong to you? The week had the same seven days as any other. What is missing is not time. What is missing is the part of it that felt like life. Perhaps it was there: a conversation on Wednesday, half an hour in the garden. It has simply disappeared under everything else.
What Seneca's contradiction does not mean
Three misunderstandings come easily. First: Seneca does not say that you should get more done. In the second chapter he goes on to criticise precisely those who turn everything into busyness. Getting more done does not mean living more. Second: he does not say that every minute must be used. Reading him that way turns Seneca into a time management guide, and he was not one. What concerns him is the question of who the time belongs to, not how much fits into it. Third: the sentence is not a verdict on you. If you think while reading that you have lost a lot of time, read it again as the opposite of a complaint: the time is still there. It is there anew every day.
A related thought: Letter to Lucilius
More than a decade after this work, in the last years of his life, Seneca wrote letters to his friend Lucilius. The very first letter begins with the same thought, only more precisely. You know the passage from lesson 0.4: some of our time is torn from us, some is taken away by stealth, some flows away. Seneca writes this as an old man, after he himself had lost much and wasted some. The basic thought had stayed the same for more than a decade: life is not short. It only gets lost to us in different ways. The course follows these ways in modules 2, 3 and 4.
A moment of stillness
Think of the past week. Ask yourself quietly: Which moment of it was life, not only time? Let one come, without searching.
To take with you
Life is not short. Part of it is life, the rest is merely time, and I can learn to see the difference.
Questions for reflection
- When did you last think that life or time is too short? What were you looking at when you thought it?
- Which part of your last week was life for you, not merely time?
- What surprises you about Seneca's contradiction of the complaint?