Module 9 · Gratitude

The first book

9.1

What you will learn

You know book I of the Meditations, in which Marcus Aurelius lists what he learned from whom, and you understand why a book about serenity begins with thanks.

Most books begin with a thesis. The Meditations begin with a grandfather.

“From my grandfather Verus [I learned] good morals and the government of my temper.”

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations I.1, translated by George Long (1862)

This is the first sentence of the book. No thought about the world, no doctrine, no admonition. A man remembers what he received from another person. And what he names here, the government of his temper, is close to what this whole course is about: serenity.

You already read this sentence in lesson 0.7, on the map of the nine themes. Now, at the end of the path through the themes, we return to it. For the question of this module is simple and deep at once: to whom do I owe who I am?

A list of names

Book I has seventeen sections. Marcus Aurelius writes almost every one of them to the same pattern: a name, and after it what he learned from that person. From his grandfather, good morals. From his father, he writes, modesty and a manly character. From his mother, piety and beneficence and a simple way of living. Then come the teachers: Diognetus, Rusticus, Apollonius, Sextus, Alexander, Fronto, Catulus, Maximus and others. Towards the end stands a long section about his father, and at the very close a thanks to the gods.

Historians believe that the father in the long section I.16 is not his birth father, who died early, but Antoninus Pius, who adopted him and was emperor before him. Marcus Aurelius simply calls him “my father”.

The section to the gods begins like this:

“To the gods I am indebted for having good grandfathers, good parents, a good sister, good teachers, good associates, good kinsmen and friends, nearly everything good.”

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations I.17, translated by George Long (1862)

And it ends with a sentence in which everything gathers:

“… for all these things require the help of the gods and fortune.”

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations I.17, translated by George Long (1862)

This is Marcus Aurelius's view. He sees in his life a providence that he ascribes to the gods. You do not have to share this view to understand the movement in it: he looks at his life and sees first what was given to him.

Written far from Rome

It is assumed that Marcus Aurelius wrote his thanks to grandfather, mother and teachers not in a quiet study in Rome, but far away, in difficult years, as an older man, many of those he names long dead.

We understand this as a quiet pointer. Gratitude here is not a mood for good days. It arises in the middle of a hard situation, and it holds on to something the situation cannot take away.

Why does this come first?

It is assumed that book I was not written first, but was placed at the beginning later or came into being on its own. That is not certain. What is certain is only that it stands at the beginning today, and that it sounds different from the other eleven books: more ordered, more personal, like a letter to one's own past.

We understand the book's position this way: before Marcus Aurelius admonishes himself about how he should be, he looks at where what he already is comes from. The serenity he seeks in the following books does not begin from nothing. It has forerunners. A grandfather lived it before him.

What Marcus Aurelius does not write

What is missing is striking. In book I Marcus Aurelius hardly writes about his own achievements. He does not write: I learned this because I was diligent. He writes: from him I have it. Even where he mentions himself, in the thanks to the gods, he names what he was spared from rather than what he achieved.

Nor does he write only about role models without faults. In the section to the gods he gives thanks that he never did anything to Rusticus of which he had occasion to repent, though he was often “out of humour” with him. More on that in the next lesson.

What gratitude does not mean here

Three misunderstandings are worth naming. Gratitude here does not mean approving of everything that has happened to you. Marcus Aurelius lists what he learned from people, not that his life was free of hardship. Nor does it mean making yourself small: whoever recognises what they owe to others loses nothing of themselves. And it is not a duty owed to someone. Book I is addressed to no one. Most of those he thanks never read it.

In everyday life

You are sitting in a meeting, and someone reacts irritably to your proposal. You notice that you stay calm and ask a question instead of striking back. Later it occurs to you where you have that from: from a teacher who, many years ago, never raised her voice in a noisy classroom. You have not seen her in a long time. But her calm is still there, in you, in this moment. That is the kind of memory book I is made of.

A related thought: Epictetus

Epictetus teaches at the beginning of his handbook:

“Of things some are in our power, and others are not.”

Epictetus, Encheiridion, chapter 1, translated by George Long (1877)

You have known this sentence since module 1. In book I a quiet side of it appears. Who shaped you, where you grew up, which people you met: that was not in your power. It was given to you. What is in your power is how you look at it today and what you pass on from it.

A moment of stillness

Think of a person from whom you have something good in you. Say their name quietly, once. Then stay for one breath with what they gave you.

To take with you

Serenity does not begin with me. Someone lived it before me.

Questions for reflection

  1. If you were to write a first book about yourself: whose name would stand in the first sentence?
  2. What surprises you about the fact that Marcus Aurelius begins his book with thanks and not with a doctrine?