What is not good for the swarm
8.1
What you will learn
You know Marcus Aurelius's thought that what is not good for the whole is not good for the individual either (VI.54).
A bee on its own does not survive for long. Marcus Aurelius made a single sentence out of this image, shorter than most of his notes, and yet one of the most important.
“That which is not good for the swarm, neither is it good for the bee.”
Marcus Aurelius, Meditations VI.54, translated by George Long (1862)
Marcus Aurelius writes this sentence without explanation. It stands on its own, like a maxim. Anyone who knows bees understands it at once: a bee lives from the swarm and for the swarm. What weakens the hive weakens the bee too, even if it does not feel it at the moment.
The human being as a part
For Marcus Aurelius the same holds for people. He sees every individual as part of a larger whole: of people among one another, and beyond that of nature as a whole. This is a basic conviction of the Stoa. It is assumed that it was the Stoics who championed this thought: all people are fellow citizens of a single world, regardless of origin and rank.
Marcus Aurelius derives this step by step in one passage:
“If our intellectual part is common, the reason also, in respect of which we are rational beings, is common: if this is so, common also is the reason which commands us what to do, and what not to do; if this is so, there is a common law also; if this is so, we are fellow-citizens; if this is so, we are members of some political community; if this is so, the world is in a manner a state …”
Marcus Aurelius, Meditations IV.4, translated by George Long (1862)
The chain is simple: we can all think. So we share something. Those who share something belong together. This is Marcus Aurelius's claim, and it has a particular note because it comes from an emperor who ruled over a world empire. He does not speak of Rome as the state, but of the world.
How to test the sentence
The bee sentence is also a touchstone. When you do something, you can ask: does this serve only me, or does it harm what I belong to? Marcus Aurelius assumes that what harms the whole does you no good in the end either, even if it brings you an advantage at the moment.
In another passage he turns the thought around. What happens to an individual he sees as something that serves the whole (X.6). This is the more difficult part of his view, and it hangs on his belief in a universal reason that orders everything. You do not have to follow that belief. We understand the bee sentence first in its simple direction: what harms the whole harms me too.
How we understand the whole
We understand the whole in this course not as something distant. It begins where you live: in your family, your house, your street, your work. It reaches further, to people you will never meet, and to the nature you live from. You do not have to think about the entire universe to understand the sentence. It is enough to think of a household in which everyone looks only to themselves. No one lives well there.
This has more to do with serenity than it first appears. Whoever sees themselves only as an individual carries everything alone. Every slight, every loss, every effort is then theirs alone. Whoever sees themselves as part of a whole can carry some things more easily. They are not the centre, and they are not alone.
A thought for hard days
Marcus Aurelius did not write the bee sentence down in quiet times. As you read in the opening module, large parts of the Meditations probably came into being in years of plague and heavy duties, far from Rome. An emperor in that situation would have had every reason to think only of himself and his power. Instead he reminds himself that he is part of a whole and should serve it.
We understand this as a pointer for our own hard days. When everything closes in, our attention tends to narrow to what is our own: my worry, my irritation, my problem. That is understandable. The bee sentence opens the view again a little. It does not ask whether your worry is justified. It reminds you that you do not carry it alone in an empty world, but in the midst of others who carry their own. Sometimes a burden becomes lighter as soon as you see that others have one too, and that you can help one another.
In everyday life
In an open-plan office everyone sets the heating the way it suits them. One person is freezing, one is sweating, everyone is annoyed, and the bill goes up. Then the team agrees on one temperature. No one gets exactly what they wanted, but everyone is better off than before. That is the bee sentence in miniature: what was not good for the whole was not good for the individual either.
What the whole does not mean
Three misunderstandings are worth naming. Being part of a whole does not mean giving yourself up or always putting your own needs last; the bee too must live for the swarm to live. It does not mean submitting to a group that does wrong; for Marcus Aurelius the whole is bound to reason and justice, not to the majority. And it does not mean that your individual life is unimportant. Without the bee there is no swarm.
A related thought: Epictetus
Marcus Aurelius passes on a saying of Epictetus that shows where, for the Stoa, the freedom of the individual remains, even in the midst of the whole:
“No man can rob us of our free will.”
Marcus Aurelius, Meditations XI.36, translated by George Long (1862)
We understand this sentence as a counterweight to the bee sentence. You belong to the whole, but your judgement and your decision about how you want to serve it remain yours. It is the distinction from module 1, here with a view to community.
A moment of stillness
Think of three people who did something for you today without your knowing them: someone who grew your food, someone who built a road, someone who supplies electricity. Stay with each of them for one breath.
To take with you
What is not good for the whole is not good for me either.
Questions for reflection
- Which wholes do you belong to right now: family, work, place, community?
- Where have you already experienced that something which harmed the whole did you no good either?