Module 7 · Everything passes

Time is a river

7.1

What you will learn

You know Marcus Aurelius's image of time as a river (IV.43) and his attitude towards transience.

Everything you hold in your hands today was not there yesterday or will not be there tomorrow. Marcus Aurelius wrote this simple thought down again and again, as if he had to tell it to himself afresh every evening.

A word of care. This module is about transience, and so also about death and loss. If you are grieving right now or going through something hard, read gently and at your own pace. You can skip a lesson at any time or come back to it later. This course is a philosophical and spiritual practice. It is not a substitute for therapy or medical treatment. If something touches you deeply, turn to a professional or to a person you trust.

A violent stream

“Time is like a river made up of the events which happen, and a violent stream; for as soon as a thing has been seen, it is carried away, and another comes in its place, and this will be carried away too.”

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations IV.43, translated by George Long (1862)

Marcus Aurelius writes this sentence without complaint. He states what he sees. Things appear, and hardly are they there before the current takes them. Something new takes their place, and that too will soon be carried on.

The image is old. It is assumed that Marcus Aurelius was thinking here of Heraclitus, a Greek thinker who lived centuries before him and to whom the thought that everything flows is attributed. Marcus Aurelius names Heraclitus elsewhere in his notes. But he does not turn the image into a doctrine about the world. He turns it into a practice for himself: to look at how quickly everything passes, and not to be caught off guard by it.

Everything which belongs to the body is a stream

One of the densest passages in the Meditations stands at the end of the second book. There Marcus Aurelius gathers the whole of human life into a few lines:

“Of human life the time is a point, and the substance is in a flux, and the perception dull, and the composition of the whole body subject to putrefaction, and the soul a whirl, and fortune hard to divine, and fame a thing devoid of judgment. And, to say all in a word, everything which belongs to the body is a stream, and what belongs to the soul is a dream and vapour, and life is a warfare and a stranger's sojourn, and after-fame is oblivion. What then is that which is able to conduct a man? One thing, and only one, philosophy.”

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations II.17, translated by George Long (1862)

On a first reading this sounds bleak. A point, a dream and vapour, oblivion. But the passage does not stop there. It ends with a question: what is able to conduct a man? And with an answer that for Marcus Aurelius is not an escape but a foothold: philosophy. By this he does not mean books and theories. He means a way of living that reckons with transience instead of closing its eyes to it.

This is Marcus Aurelius's claim. He believes that a clear look at passing makes us calmer, not more afraid. Whether that is true for you is not something you have to decide today. This module invites you to try it out.

An emperor who knew this

As you read in the opening module, Marcus Aurelius probably wrote many of these notes in the last years of his life. He had lost a great deal. It is assumed that several of his children died young. A plague moved through the empire in those years. For him the thought of transience was not a mental exercise but daily life. All the more remarkable is the tone of his sentences: sober, often strict with himself, but rarely despairing.

How we understand the river

We understand the image of the river as an invitation not to cling to things that by their nature pass by. A river is not sad. It is alive because it moves. Water that stands still goes stale. If you see time as a stream, every moment becomes precious, precisely because it does not stay.

That does not mean nothing is allowed to hurt you any more. Whoever loves something will be sad when it goes. Marcus Aurelius does not ask you to stop feeling. He suggests that you not be surprised when the water flows on.

In everyday life

You find an old photograph while tidying up. People who were young then. A house that looks different now. A dress that no longer exists. For a moment you feel the stream: everything in this picture has been carried on, you included. That can make you wistful. But it can also remind you not to overlook today. It too will one day be an old photograph.

What transience does not mean

Three misunderstandings are worth naming. To consider transience does not mean that nothing has meaning. For Marcus Aurelius it is the other way round: because everything passes, it matters how you act now. It also does not mean withdrawing inwardly and no longer loving anything so that nothing can hurt any more. And it does not mean thinking about death all the time. Marcus Aurelius looks at passing in order to become clearer in life, not in order to leave life.

A related thought: Epictetus

Marcus Aurelius quotes Epictetus, the teacher he never met, several times in his notes. Once he copies out a very short sentence of his:

“Thou art a little soul bearing about a corpse, as Epictetus used to say …”

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations IV.41, translated by George Long (1862)

That sounds harsh. We understand it as a reminder of how things stand: the body belongs to the stream, it ages and passes. What you think, how you judge and how you act, that is where the Stoa sees what is really in your power. It is the distinction from module 1, practised here on the hardest subject of all.

A moment of stillness

Listen for a moment to a sound that is coming and going right now: a car, a bird, your breath. Notice how it arises and fades. Let it go without following it.

To take with you

Time is a river. What I cannot hold on to, I may notice while it is there.

Questions for reflection

  1. Where in your life right now do you feel how quickly something is passing?
  2. What becomes more precious to you when you remember that it will not stay?