Module 5 · Other people

They do not know better

5.1

What you will learn

You know Marcus Aurelius's view that people act out of ignorance of the good, and you understand why he draws serenity from it rather than anger.

Most of the things that unsettle us have a face. It is rarely the weather or the course of the world. It is a person who says something, does something, or leaves something undone.

Marcus Aurelius knew this well. As emperor he was surrounded by people every day: officials, senators, advisers, petitioners, courtiers, relatives. Many wanted something from him, some flattered him, some worked against him. One of his best-known notes begins not with a thought about the world but with a preparation for exactly these people.

“Begin the morning by saying to thyself, I shall meet with the busybody, the ungrateful, arrogant, deceitful, envious, unsocial. All these things happen to them by reason of their ignorance of what is good and evil.”

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations II.1, translated by George Long (1862)

You met the first part of this note in lesson 4.2 as a resolution for the morning. Here we look at its core: the reason Marcus Aurelius gives for the behaviour of others.

Ignorance, not malice

Marcus Aurelius writes that the faults of others come from “their ignorance of what is good and evil.” This is an old teaching of the Stoa, traced back to Socrates: no one does wrong on purpose. Whoever acts unkindly, greedily or dishonestly takes that, in the moment, to be right or advantageous. They are mistaken about what is truly good.

This is Marcus Aurelius's claim, and it can be disputed. Some people seem to know very well what they are doing. But for Marcus Aurelius the sentence is less a theory about others than an instruction to himself. It changes the question. Instead of “How can they?” he asks: “What do they not see?”

We understand this shift as the real gain. Whoever sees an enemy in the other is already in a fight. Whoever sees in the other someone who is mistaken can stay calm without agreeing with them.

Akin, not foreign

Marcus Aurelius goes further in the same note. He writes that the nature of the one who does wrong is akin to him, “not [only] of the same blood or seed, but that it participates in [the same] intelligence and [the same] portion of the divinity.” And then follows an image that is easy to remember:

“… I can neither be injured by any of them, for no one can fix on me what is ugly, nor can I be angry with my kinsman, nor hate him. For we are made for co-operation, like feet, like hands, like eyelids, like the rows of the upper and lower teeth.”

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations II.1, translated by George Long (1862)

Two hands work together. The upper and lower rows of teeth do too. If one hand strikes the other, the body injures itself. That, says Marcus Aurelius, is what happens when people work against one another. This is Marcus Aurelius's view of the world: all human beings share in the same reason, and so they belong together, the difficult ones included.

Made for one another

Elsewhere he puts the same thought into two sentences, so brief that you could write them on a slip of paper:

“Men exist for the sake of one another. Teach them then or bear with them.”

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations VIII.59, translated by George Long (1862)

Teach or bear with: these are the two possibilities he sees. If you can show someone what they do not see, do it. If not, bear with them. A third possibility, one we often choose, does not appear in his note: being silently annoyed with them, for hours, without changing anything.

What is in your power here

In the first module you met the distinction that runs through the whole course: some things are up to you, others are not. With other people this distinction becomes especially clear. What someone says, how they think, whether they change: that is not up to you. What you make of it, how you answer, and what judgement you form about them: that is up to you.

Marcus Aurelius says in his note: “I can neither be injured by any of them”. He does not mean that others cannot do anything to us. He means that they cannot make us act badly ourselves. The injury he wants to protect himself from is injury to his own character.

In everyday life

A colleague replies sharply to your suggestion in a meeting. You feel the heat rising. An answer is already forming, just as sharp. Now imagine you had read the sentence this morning: They do not know better. Perhaps they are afraid for their own project. Perhaps they did not understand what you meant. The sentence does not make their remark any friendlier. But it creates a small distance in which you can choose whether to strike back or ask what they mean.

What this does not mean

Three misunderstandings are worth naming. Marcus Aurelius's attitude does not mean approving of everything others do; he calls their faults by name, a whole list of them. It does not mean placing yourself above others, as if you always knew what is good; as you will see in the next lesson, he counts himself among those who often do wrong. And it does not mean putting up with everything. Staying calm does not mean accepting harm: setting boundaries, protecting yourself and getting help are in your power too.

What he learned from Rusticus

Marcus Aurelius came to know the teaching of Epictetus through his teacher Rusticus, as you read in lesson 0.4. From Rusticus, he writes, he also learned something that fits this theme: “with respect to those who have offended me by words, or done me wrong, to be easily disposed to be pacified and reconciled, as soon as they have shown a readiness to be reconciled” (book I, 7). Notice the last part. Being reconcilable here does not mean running after everyone, but keeping the door open when the other takes a step.

A moment of stillness

Think of a person who has annoyed you recently. Say inwardly, without mockery: They do not know better. Notice what happens in you, whether resistance, relief, or nothing at all.

To take with you

What others do is not up to me. How I meet them is up to me.

Questions for reflection

  1. With which person do you find it hardest to think: They do not know better?
  2. When have you yourself done something that harmed others because you did not know better in that moment?
  3. Where in your life right now would teaching be fitting, and where bearing with?