Module 10 · Closing

Being a good man, not talking about it

10.1

What you will learn

You know Marcus Aurelius's call to stop talking about what a good man ought to be and to be one (X.16), and you see what that means for the end of a course.

In this course you have read, reflected and written a great deal. At the very end, of all places, stands a sentence that calls all of that into question.

“No longer talk at all about the kind of man that a good man ought to be, but be such.”

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations X.16, translated by George Long (1862)

Marcus Aurelius writes this sentence to himself. He is the man who filled twelve books with thoughts about how one should live. And in the middle of those books he calls out to himself: Stop talking. Be it.

We understand this not as a rejection of reflection. The Meditations are themselves one long act of reflection. But Marcus Aurelius measures his reflection against something else: whether it arrives in his actions. A thought that remains only a thought is not worthless to him, but it is not yet finished.

No sermons

You remember Rusticus from lesson 9.2. Among the first things he taught Marcus Aurelius was not to be led astray “to delivering little hortatory orations”. Many years later, as emperor, Marcus Aurelius writes this lesson down again in another form. This time he is not preaching to others. He admonishes himself not to mistake even the preaching to himself for living.

This is Marcus Aurelius's experience, as we read it: a person can know very precisely how they want to be, and still not be it. Knowing alone is not enough. That is why he returns in his notes again and again to the same thoughts, not because he had forgotten them, but because he does not yet live them.

A day's work

What does it mean, then, to be a good person? Marcus Aurelius rarely describes it in grand terms. Mostly he describes an ordinary day, in a sentence you have met several times in this course:

“Every moment think steadily as a Roman and a man to do what thou hast in hand with perfect and simple dignity, and feeling of affection, and freedom, and justice …”

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations II.5, translated by George Long (1862)

For him, what he had in hand was the work of an emperor: court cases, letters, audiences. Yours looks different. But the words fit any day's work: with dignity, simply, with affection, freedom and justice. None of them requires a special situation. Each can begin today, with the next task, in the next conversation.

A little further on in the same section he writes: “Thou seest how few the things are, the which if a man lays hold of, he is able to live a life which flows in quiet”. This is Marcus Aurelius's claim, and perhaps he exaggerates, because for him, few does not mean easy. But he is right that it takes no long list. It takes a few things, often repeated.

The fountain within

Where is the strength for this to come from, if not from still more reading? Marcus Aurelius answers with an image you already read in lesson 0.6:

“Look within. Within is the fountain of good, and it will ever bubble up, if thou wilt ever dig.”

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations VII.59, translated by George Long (1862)

We understand this image as the answer to the sentence about the good man. Being a good person does not mean fulfilling someone else's rule. It means reaching a fountain that is already there, and digging again whenever it has been buried. In this course you have dug in many places: in your judgement, in your mornings, in your anger, in your thanks.

What this does not mean

This sentence invites two misunderstandings. It does not mean that after this course you must be a finished person. Marcus Aurelius wrote it, it is assumed, as an older man, after decades of practice, and he wrote it to himself because he was not yet there. And it does not mean that reading and writing were pointless. Without reflection you would not know what you want to act on. The sentence only shifts the weight: from knowing to doing.

In everyday life

You have resolved to be more patient with your father, who often repeats himself on the phone. You have thought about it, written it down, talked it over with a friend. Then he calls, and he tells the same story for the third time. Now is the moment Marcus Aurelius is talking about. It is not yesterday's reflection that counts, but whether you are listening now. Perhaps you manage it, perhaps not. Tomorrow he will call again.

At the end of a course

This last module has three lessons. This first one reminds you where all the reading is aimed. The second shows the nine themes as a daily practice. The third gives you room to look back on your path and to write your own meditations. After that the course is over, and the day's work begins.

A moment of stillness

Think of one single thing you will do today. Not an intention, but an action. Picture yourself doing it, with care and without haste.

To take with you

I do not need to go on talking about what a good person is. I can begin today to be one.

Questions for reflection

  1. Where do you notice that you have been thinking about something for a long time instead of doing it?
  2. Which one attitude from this course do you want to make visible in your day's work?